Although
tremendous amounts of money, time, and effort are
dedicated to financial agreements, companies often
undervalue the key intellectual assets - patents,
trademarks, copyrights, brand names, and trade secrets -
that make most companies truly valuable.
To help companies
understand the full value of the intellectual assets
within a transaction, Mr. Gordon Petrash, a
PricewaterhouseCoopers partner within the firm's
Intellectual Asset Management Practice, has developed a
list of five of the most commonly made intellectual asset
management mistakes in mergers and acquisitions and the
solutions to those mistakes.
Mistake No. 1: Being
unaware of a company's key intellectual assets and their
economic value when entering into a joint venture,
divestiture, merger, or acquisition.
Solution: Understanding
the key intellectual assets on both sides of a deal
should be fundamental in most industries, particularly
technology. Once assets are identified, there are several
readily available methodologies designed to help you
estimate their value.
Mistake No. 2:
Undervaluing intellectual assets. Many dealmakers value
intellectual assets in their present context rather than
in their new context, thus missing the value of the
synergy.
Solution: The value
contribution of intellectual assets should be linked to
both their short- and long-term benefits. To assist in
this process, seek individuals who understand the
economic value of intellectual assets and examine the
business plans with and without the intellectual
assets.
Mistake No. 3: Brand-name
recognition, one of the most costly types of intellectual
assets a company may have built, is frequently
undervalued.
Solution: Often, a
company benefits greatly by simply being able to
associate itself with another more recognized company.
This needs to be considered as part of the value
contribution and compensated for, particularly when it is
valued against having to build the brand equity from
scratch.
Mistake No. 4: Reviewing
the value of intellectual assets after a deal is
finalized.
Solution: If companies
verify all aspects of the intellectual assets either
before or during negotiations, they increase their
ability to negotiate and protect themselves from
surprises.
Mistake No. 5:
Negotiating the value of intellectual assets as a whole
rather than individually.
Solution: For
intellectual asset valuation, the whole often is not as
valuable as the parts individually. Value is often lost
when companies assign a general estimated value to all of
their intellectual assets. When proper focus and
understanding is given to each intellectual asset, the
process usually results in consistently higher
valuations.